Media retailers are being shut down. Political opponents are being locked up. A semi-frozen conflict continues to simmer within the East. And but, overseas speaking heads are nonetheless applauding Ukraine’s flip to the West as an ideal achievement.
In a latest article, ‘Ukraine’s Harmful Success’, veteran Moscow critic Edward Lucas argued that “Ukraine’s nearly unimaginable progress since 1991 is a nightmare for Russia.” The crux of his argument is that the nation’s stance towards Ukraine is just not dictated by Kiev’s home anti-Kremlin posture. Russia, he says, is fearful that the success of Ukraine can undermine the nation’s legitimacy at house.
The argument is sort of similar to that of an article written two months earlier by Arseniy Yatsenyuk, Ukraine’s former prime minister. Yatsenyuk argues that NATO expansionism is just not driving Russia away from the West, however that failure to increase the bloc will probably be a victory for President Vladimir Putin.
“So as to not lose Russia endlessly, the West should do all the things doable and extra to combine Ukraine and different international locations in our area right into a United Europe, and due to this fact into NATO and the EU,” he wrote. “That is precisely what Mr. Putin fears as a result of Ukraine’s freedom means one thing greater than our nationwide pursuits. It proves that Russia too could be free and that Putin is just not indispensable.”
Additionally on rt.com
Ukraine’s drive to hitch US-led NATO bloc & deliver Western forces nearer to Russian border presents severe safety dangers – Kremlin
Lucas is a journalist turned lobbyist, working as a senior fellow at CEPA, a stress group which promotes American pursuits in Jap Europe. It has obtained funding from the US State Division and a variety of protection contractors, corresponding to Raytheon and Lockheed Martin. Yatsenyuk was chosen by Washington to steer Ukraine a number of weeks earlier than the US-backed 2014 coup, which was revealed in a leaked cellphone name between Assistant Secretary of State Victoria Nuland and the American Ambassador to Ukraine Geoffrey Pyatt.
Kiev is shedding its overseas sponsors
The disaster in Ukraine derives from the zero-sum safety structure in Europe, which compelled Kiev to align itself both with the West or with Russia. The ‘civilizational selection’ imposed on the nation by the West has fragmented a deep divide in its society, which its leaders at the moment are responding to with a crackdown on the political opposition, the media and protesters which can be deemed not adverse sufficient about Russia. The phrases imposed on Ukraine by the US implies a pathway to NATO enlargement that Russia deems to be an existential risk, and Moscow has responded by upholding clear crimson strains.
Recognizing the failure of the zero-sum strategy to Ukraine, a number of Western powers have begun distancing themselves from the nation and strolling again the prospect of EU and NATO membership.
Neither Washington nor Kiev need the return of the Donbass area to Ukraine beneath the circumstances outlined within the Minsk Settlement, and as a substitute have spent the previous few years sanctioning Russia and arming Ukraine within the hopes of renegotiating the peace settlement. The technique resulted in spectacular failure because the mobilization of Ukrainian troops in Jap Ukraine earlier this 12 months resulted in a army stand-off with Russia, through which each the West made it clear they didn’t intend to comply with Ukraine right into a conflict.
Following the failure of the technique, the US and its European companions have rising issues that the zero-sum strategy to Ukraine threatens to completely alienate Russia and presumably cement a de facto Russian-Chinese language alliance. Moreover, an more and more authoritarian Ukraine seems to be shifting towards socio-economic collapse and may drag the West into a serious conflict with Russia.
The standard propaganda pitch
The articles by Yatsenyuk and Lucas are a response to the West distancing itself from Ukraine. On the core of anti-Russian propaganda is to current all competing safety pursuits as a battle between democracy and authoritarianism.
Additionally on rt.com
Out of Afghan frying pan & into Ukrainian hearth? America’s empire builders have one other pawn to gas their apocalyptic chess recreation
Conflicts outlined by competing safety pursuits are resolved by compromise, however these deemed a wrestle between good and evil have to be resolved by the forces of sunshine defeating the forces of darkness.
Propaganda is the science of convincing an viewers by bypassing cause. Morally dichotomous stereotypes of a morally superior energy versus an inferior one are created to filter by means of the complexities of the world in a way that may solely lead to one conclusion. Presenting all occasions by means of the prism of democracy versus authoritarianism is the trendy equal of the colonial binary division of civilized peoples versus savages.
The language is subsequently distorted by the stereotypes that emerge from this. George Orwell’s idea of ‘newspeak’ entailed utilizing easy language and dichotomous phrases that arouse and distinction favorable attitudes versus adverse attitudes. Distorting the language meant that “Battle Is Peace, Freedom Is Slavery, and Ignorance Is Energy.” A brand new and easy language has equally been constructed in the true world through which the dialogue of goal realities are changed with distorted phrases: subversion is democracy promotion, coup is democratic revolution, conflict is humanitarian intervention, and violation of worldwide regulation is a rules-based worldwide system. In distinction, any motion by Russia is uncritically accompanied by phrases corresponding to regime, authoritarian, aggressor, imperialist, sphere of affect and different phrases that develop a Pavlovian reflex of contempt.
The technique of Yatsenyuk and Lucas may be very interesting as Washington eagerly makes an attempt to command the loyalty of its allies vis-à-vis Russia and China by framing all worldwide politics as a wrestle of democracy versus authoritarianism. The general public has additionally been wired for such an interpretation. When was the final time any of us opened up a newspaper and examine competing safety pursuits between NATO and Russia? The stereotype of Western civilization in opposition to Russian barbarians has 500 years of continuity, through which goal info change into a mere background noise of a Manichean wrestle between good and evil.
Returning to actuality
If propaganda is outlined as persuasion by bypassing cause, the alternative is a return to goal and measurable info. In spite of everything, Russia’s optimistic relations with East Asian democracies corresponding to Japan and South Korea on its Jap borders is a transparent indication that Moscow is just not involved about NATO’s ‘democratic values’, fairly Moscow reacts to NATO as a army bloc that subverts, expands and intervenes.
Additionally on rt.com
Biden has promised to impose sanctions in opposition to Russian-German Nord Stream 2 pipeline if issues come up for Ukraine – Zelensky
How can we measure Ukraine’s “unimaginable progress” since 1991 that has change into a nightmare for Russia? As argued by Ukraine’s principal opposition chief, Victor Medvedchuk, it’s the solely former Soviet republic that has not recovered its financial power because the USSR broke up in 1991. The Ukrainian financial system has proven potential when it was positioned as a bridge between the West and Russia, and collapsed when Ukraine started positioning itself as an anti-Russian bulwark.
Ukraine could nicely now lose its standing as a fuel transit state, and the remainder of the financial system might subsequently collapse with out overseas help. The Estonian President Kersti Kaljulaid, one of the keen supporters of the Maidan rebellion in Kiev, just lately warned her residents in opposition to investing in Ukraine. The nation is now the second-poorest state in Europe by way of official GDP per capita, the oligarchs have overwhelming management, and the inhabitants has plummeted from 52 million in 1991 to someplace between 30-35 million, in keeping with quite a few credible estimates. The precise determine is unclear as a result of, extremely, Kiev hasn’t performed a census for over 20 years.
The efforts to promote an anti-Russian authorities in Ukraine as ‘democratic’ equally conflicts with goal realities, corresponding to how NATO membership was provided to Ukraine in 2008 when solely a small fraction of the inhabitants desired membership. Likewise, Washington backed the toppling of the democratically elected president in a coup that didn’t have democratic majority help by the inhabitants.
President Zelensky gained his nation’s high job on a political platform of restoring peaceable relations with Russia, and his reputation has fallen steadily after that goal was deserted. In February, Kiev closed down a number of impartial media retailers accused of being too Russia-friendly. Then, in Could, Kiev positioned the primary opposition chief, Medvedchuk, beneath home arrest. In April 2021, Ukraine arrested 60 demonstrators that weren’t accused of partaking in violence, however as a substitute expressing sympathetic views towards Russia.
In the meantime, Strana, the nation’s third hottest information web site has been banned, merely for adopting a important posture towards Zelensky’s authorities.
Additionally on rt.com
US & Ukraine protection ministers signal settlement for intensified army cooperation forward of Zelensky’s first go to to White Home
Additionally ignored is how Kiev’s partnership with neo-Nazi teams like Proper Sektor and militias such the Azov Batallion, who brazenly put on swastikas, has induced nice concern elsewhere, together with with revelations reported by Israeli media.
Appeasing these teams has positioned important stress on Zelensky to escalate conflicts within the Donbass and with Russia, because the failure to take action could lead to them marching once more in opposition to the authorities in Kiev. Nonetheless, within the language of identification politics, Lucas reassures us that these goal realities of racism and nationalism aren’t any large deal, as evidenced by Zelensky’s Jewish ethnicity and Ukraine’s first black MP profitable an Olympic gold medal.
By conflating anti-Russian insurance policies with prosperity and democracy, the supposed supporters of Ukraine are pushing their geopolitical pawn into the abyss and chalking it up as “unimaginable progress.”
On this, they’re repeating the errors they made in Georgia, a decade in the past, the place the regime of Mikhail Saakashvili was supplied with cowl, even because it drifted towards elevated authoritarianism, and corruption. Ultimately, the home of playing cards collapsed.
Assume your pals would have an interest? Share this story!
The statements, views and opinions expressed on this column are solely these of the writer and don’t essentially symbolize these of RT.